Sunday, July 6, 2008

THE PROCESS OF INTERPRETATION ...

... is a circular one
calling for a movement
from a part to whole
and back to the part.

The paradigm
for this hermeneutical circle,
or, better, helix,
is the understanding of a sentence.

This requires
an understanding of individual words
which requires
an understanding of the sentence
which requires
an understanding of the paragraph
which requires
an understanding of individual sentences
which requires
an understanding of the language and social practices
with which it is interwoven.

Coming to understand a text
is a process of temporarily progressive feedback.
I understand the first word in a sentence
in the light of an expectation
regarding what kind of word will follow,
and likewise
for the words that do follow.
But
my expectations are not always fulfilled,
and they are usually fairly general.
By the time I have reached the full stop
or the end of the paragraph,
hitherto possible meanings
of later sentences or paragraphs
may have surprises in store for me
that will call for a revision
in my understanding of the text so far.
This is why
the so-called
hermeneutical circle
is really a spiral ....
John Llwelyn , Beyond Metaphysics?
The Hermeneutic Circle in Contemporary Continental Philosophy,
Alantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities, 1985.

No comments: